Post "Cupcakes [Ad-Free]" by "CreepCast" from patreon

Mouse

I always find myself back at this story. by far the best creepcast ep ever

jo

this is my favorite thing to listen to when i have one hour left on 3rd shift and need something to make me not wanna die

Chris_canned_bread

Guys idk if I can finish this one

Kingofgam305

When I saw this pop up on my page I was like “oh great I love crash out eps” I was not prepared for how truly amazing and at some points actually horrifying this story was the think fast line and buzz saw quote will live in my head forever. After this story I hope they’ll read one piece to help me forget

Cherry

For anyone who really lika this story there's an amazing comic series going on! The art is amazing and the gore is well done definitely reccomend https://www.fanon.co/fanfics/0149-Cupcakes-alternative-story/episodes/Episode-1

MLGorilla

Yooo always

Heidi Lake

I think it would be fun if you guys did a video of lowest rated creepy pastas

Jo Williams

who up being gay asf rn

Mouse

This might be one of my top three episodes ever. perfect mix of comedy and horror. Cinema.

Kaye

I’m BEGGING, please do part 2 of Thing in the Basement.

Rose Red Lyla

This really creeped my cast, haven't heard this one since well, since my first venture into Bronydom, my favorite follow-up was "Silent Ponyville" a sequel where Pinkie confronts her past and actually ends up regretting her psychopathic tendencies! Actually heartbreaking, the fanfiction was as far as my interests went, we need more darkness in our children's cartoons.

Dylan East

Also I fucking can’t with the rascal flatts instrumental playing in the background 😂

Dylan East

Ngl I’m bout to for another “Spire in the Woods” esque episode

Snoobert

this was a banger unironically.

Connbarn

Yeah right Isaiah you’re “looking up” the lore about mlp that you have been dying to talk to someone about

Uncle Fatso

Damn it's been a while since I've heard this story. My ex was really into MLP so much so she had got a tattoo of her OC. Because of that I have an uncomfortable amount of knowledge about the show. but listening to these guys experience the "lore" for the first time through a crappy horror story is just wonderful.

Joseph Greenwood

Unironically better than Borassca Part 5

Okito studio

You guys should read and react to the weird birds arg

Heather King

.mov series 🤩 please watch on here 🙏 😆😆😆

TNHD

Pleeeease make your posts downloadable or give us an RSS feed so we can listen to them at work. Love the content guys!

Jacob B.

Maybe his mother and law was poisoning him cause he was a fucking psycho

Josh

Why. Did. This. Go. So hard. So damn hilarious and some how good the writing make it

JokesOnU

Literally the funniest CC yet lmao. Thoroughly entertaining

Kiwi

Now we need to see them read other MLP creepypastas

Jessica Nova

This went so hard. It had no business! loved this

Golugore

Loved this video guys! I am happy I subscribed to the patreon! Long time fan of both your channels and creepcast. Would love for you guys to read this story next: https://www.reddit.com/r/HeadOfSpectre/comments/mrirfj/i_work_in_a_prison_for_monsters_i_interviewed_the/?rdt=53727 Been hoping yall would come across it and like it!

Light

It’s bold of Isaiah to assume that anything could be considered “safe” on the internet lol

Bryce Bailey

oh!

foxyladiesinc

Now whenever my coworkers play Rascal Flatts I'll be at my table having PTSD, as God intended.

Queen_Of_Empion

I watched My Little Pony while I was in college as a way to decompress from studying 😂 honestly one of the lesser cringy kid shows with some decent values and plot lines.

Gabe ottman

I wish we got stickers

IKE

Can’t use the same music in a little pony episode

Goblin Sharks

oh dude, i played the crappy android fangame of cupcakes that was called pinkamina.

The Gobby Cottage

Furries yiffed so bronies could clop

PinkiePantz

As a mlp and CreepCast fan this is a joyous day. (One of the 7 female viewers)

Gracie Webb

my little pony honestly doesnt even feel real, like i have never not once seen an episode so i just dont believe its real lol

Peytonic

honestly a bonus episode where the two just go on a deep dive into MLP lore would be hilarious

kalvinsdead

great now watch all the old shitty sfm my little pony films

Alichan

I don't want this to come off as soliciting, so I'm posting here instead of the subreddit. I have a friend who used to read pony fan fictions back in the day and got fairly popular, Azekahh. They've also read creepy pastas and they're a fan of the ol' creepy cast. They don't make that sort of content as much / any more, but I thought it would be cool to mention them to the guys. Maybe the guys can get a good goof and gaff.

Asher Malone

"Do not cite the Deep Magic to me, Witch. I was there when it was written"

oli

YESSSS

JakeWhyman

oh

Sam

You know in a post I made on the subreddit I mentioned that Your Secret Admirer might be too graphic for what they normally do…I think this changes my mind LMAO

AndroidPebbles

oh my god the fanart of these two either with or as mylittleponies is gonna gonna be everywhere from now on

Catsby Nimble

oh god.

Tay

I was not prepared for how fucking crazy this story was gonna be. I’ve never heard of it but holy shit. For a MLP universe horror fic like god DAMN this is insane

Kaden Sumter

Can someone please make the necessary adjustments to the Cupcakes animation by including life is a highway and Hunters voice acting

Aidan Patko

The first cut to Isiah in a dark empty room being asked about brony fanfic is too hilarious for me

Emma

okay yeah this is definitely some sort of fetish material for someone 😭😭😭

Brian Tijerina

Dear sweet lord. I signed up for the patreon because I can't get enough of your guys' chemistry and its literally like hanging out with my buddies just fuckin around and laughing during a horror movie. But this cupcakes.....every time the random drop of rascals flatts drops in the background i almost shit my pants with laughter. You guys are amazing, please don't ever stop bein you 🤣🤣💜💜💜

Logan Fields

I shared an account with my friend but after getting a shoutout I had to get my own and own up to my new pony heritage lol

Landon Reynolds

The use of ponies in this story is SHOCKINGLY similar to the use of “in Minecraft”

Shy Nep

Never thought I’d like a mlp horror story as much as I liked this but mainly thanks to hunter screaming for his life 😂😂😂

Ella Johnson

hunter fighting the brony allegations level impossible

Bob

Kassoti wrote my mother in law is poisoning me and I don't know why on nosleep. He's currently in court for murdering and chopping his wife up into tiny pieces. Apparently Sony has bought it, but it would be kind of interesting to hear you guys read it. Mainly cos I'm a sick little puppy and I like that shit

Cova Brouwer Gentry

33:02 another great YouTuber shoutout in this episode. First Jenny Nicholson now Captain Sparkles ‘Creeper Creeper Aw Man.’ I keep forgetting Isaiah is my age and probably watched all the same Minecraft shit I did.

Dick Tractor

I thoroughly enjoyed Papa's voice acting on this episode. The cries of anguish really translated well.

Cova Brouwer Gentry

14:12 Jenny Nicholson finally getting the CreepCast shoutout she deserves

res_winter

I hate how well this is written but maybe my standards have been lowered to subterranean levels

Hotborderline

This was better than I ever could have imagined! 👍👍

Laken Smyth

Papameat mentioning rainbow factory send chills up my spine from cringe. I totally forgot about that story 😭

kiera

laughing really hard at the fact that they are imagining a fuckin 10 year old to be writing this, when it seems more like a brony in their late teens or early twenties

Suspiciously_salty_mayonnaise

This is unironically such a well written torture porn and i genuinely hate the context of it

just some avocado

Legit almost had to stop eating my lunch for this lol

TheHuskyEwok

Un tapped cinema

arianna pequeña

NOO not this one omg

Connor G

This is so similar to the pony.mov series from hotdiggedydemon

FroggyFae

The music this episode is distracting but I like the rest of the video

James Cleary

This screams American Psycho

ChavezC711

Definitely the best thing you guys have read by far. Dare I say better than borrasca or left right game

Keven

READ RAINBOW FACTORY AND MY LIFE IS YOURS 🗣🗣

Spare Rib

Now this is content I'd pay for

Maria Poss

The adrenaline shot was in Pulp Fiction I believe.

Voxl Valyx

Rainbow Factory was not something I expected Hunter to know about

MrChuckleTeeth

This was fucking wild for a pony pasta lmao

Anna Gruska

this is by far the most an episode has ever made me feel sick to my stomach

Lillith

❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️❣️

Keith Henley

If I made a list of all the creep casts that made me nauseous. This would be the list.

Trevor Hayes

The What Hurts the Most instrumental playing in the background after Hunter mentions it is absolutely diabolical

Pookie_wookie

Isaiah was weirdly knowledgeable about mlp, makes one think does it not? 🤔

Mollie

This just makes me remember that when I was younger I read a Penguins of Madagascar fanfic that was essentially just the Saw movies Why did I read that

Cartyst

I didn't know I needed this

Kim Boenig

I'll be for real, I was a brony in my early high school years and ran a Facebook page for Sheriff Silverstar and another background character

kayla nicole

pls pls pls read and watch the rainbow factory after this 🙏 this is so peak

Marki Harrison

Rascal Flatts outro goes hard

vonWolfeXIII

I remember being introduced to bronies through Team Fortress 2, the haven for bronies.

cat named toebean

@11:32 why does Hunter question him like they’re not talking about MLP🤣

ihatefeet420

i need hunter to animate this story

BortBortBort

i feel you guys might benefit from foley art sounds im sure there are royalty free sounds also hunter you should totally exaggerate the voices for screaming in pain when it comes to a almost comic like reading it just feels right. but with this weeks readingi loved it so much. you all do incredible work. love all. snoobert.

Twocan

On the off weeks can we please get the old episodes uploaded to the Patreon too? YouTube is gross and nasty

Twocan

Isaiah acting like he hasn’t watched every episode

kingP13

Please don't make a habbi5 of making shorter videos I need them 3hr plus vids haha

mongojunior

I cannot believe that my first CreepCast patreon video is Cupcakes; worth every penny.

jimmy shogns

The copyright free metal music in the background gives me life

Arnulfo Martinez

i dont know why but this episode just reminded me of a creepypasta titled "Ronald McDonald house" and remembering a few details about thats sort of like this and would be funny as hell if they read that

Max Cook

This is simply fantastic

Mark Sonnet

Bronies - DO NOT be proud of yourselves 😂😂

__

Banger episode lol

Elley

I did NOT expect to enjoy this episode so much 😂 I actively winced at the “think fast” part. Sergeant Sprinkles sir, you are a psychopath (said respectively)

Kyle Todorovic

Waka waka

Mobius 1

Another banger from Big Man and Lips

Austin Massie

They mentioned this story last week.

Moominpie

As a fellow Pegasister, I loved this and couldn't stop laughing XD mlp has some really cool and disturbing episodes. I miss the bronie community (not the weird one of course). Bob's burgers episode of mlp was also reaaaally good XD (made fun of the weird and mean bronies)

Ghostlymikee

Sarah Loyd

Not too proud to admit I attended brony con in the early 2010s

Baal

Litterally the only reason I even heard about Friendship is Magic

nova

as soon as hunter yelled “making cupcakes” i realized i need full a voice acting series of them playing doki doki literature club

oli

yessss i think hannah the horrible mentioned that in her tulpa video (cant quite remember but she def mentioned mlp)

Galeisntdead

I liked mlp and the fanspace when I was 12 so every word out of Isaiahs mouth feels like sleeper agent codes. this is unbearable thank you guys

Tsar

I would pay $5 a month to see them watch and react to the Cupcake animation.

creepiana

please do an mlp grab bag i beggggg i've never read any of this stuff but i hear a lot of people talk about mlp infection? idk if its a story or not

WeebBaptism

Please read the 4chan mlp tulpa story

WeebBaptism

That one is really good. There's been a huge resurgence of mlp art on TikTok recently and I'm all for it

Littlechungus

You should read. “My property isn’t normal” I will recommend this till they read it😂

Neji

they should read dipper goes to taco bell lmao

endlessbeez

Hey everypony, what the fuck did I just listen to?

Jackie Gonzalez

The rascal flatts outro 👌

Jake Childs

They forgot about when they showed the MLP 9/11 memorial art

BetaRayBlake

Very gross!

oli

they should do a creeptv on chloë’s mlp infection au (theyre on tik tok i dont know their @) its actually rlly creative and i lowkey miss that time in the mlp fandom

oli

YESSSS OMG THEY CAN HAVE THEIR LOGOS AS THEIR CUTIE MARKS

Liz.ard

42:16 = Jesus wept

WeebBaptism

A great example where the sequel is better than the original

Creeping Karen

I kept thinking silence of the lambs guy feeding the guys brain to himself

WeebBaptism

Yes. If they keep messing up throw them in your nearest ocean. Car batteries especially

WeebBaptism

It was hard being a pinkie fan during those resurgences of people finding it and making it her whole personality

VampiresInStem

This one scared the ever loving shit out of me when I was in middle school. I was young enough that I had the toys as collector items (not young enough to actually play with them) and I had to keep Pinkie Pie in the closet for months

WeebBaptism

What other story could it have been then The Riddler?

WeebBaptism

Do you know anything about the sequels to that pasta??!

WeebBaptism

Would love a episode of them talking about bring her back and any horror movie really

GY0ZAZ

BANGER!!!!!!! Please read rocket to insanity !!!!!! Its BANGER!!!

WeebBaptism

It meant something to be horse famous back in the day. The show lost its charm when the writers started to cater heavily towards the fans.

WeebBaptism

Each of the mane 6 had their own evil counterpart as well. Some pretty uninspired but Miss Rarity had a lot of good stories about body imagery and the sacrifice for confidence.

WeebBaptism

Old and wise apparently

WeebBaptism

Is the prequel called All tongues accounted for?

Philip Hollingsworth

I think this is it. I think this is genuinely the most unhinged thing they've ever read lmao

WeebBaptism

Don't bet on sinking ships is a banger

WeebBaptism

Don't forget loss of innocence

WeebBaptism

His name is Doctor Hooves

WeebBaptism

*raises hoof* tell me about Pegasister.

WeebBaptism

I was more scared of tails doll than I was with sonic.exe. The design is just unsettling

WeebBaptism

Sweet apple massacre used to be a challenge to get through. It's the Tommy Taffy of the brony world

WeebBaptism

Technically it's be up to Celestia and Luna to release the files. It's a monarchy in equestria

Mars ✌️

YES!

Mars ✌️

Saying everypony was the most brutal part of this whole story

DifficultCombat

CREEPS i have made a discord exclusively for patreon subs here is the link https://discord.gg/eHpQaS6N

Keydoesstuff

This is gonna be a trip. Haven’t read this since I was a brony child.

Willy

I can't get the damn Anton pony out of my head now

spunkbob

im so glad yall read this, i grew up on mlp and the fandom truly scarred me as a child but it's so fun to look back on.

Dylan Mares

This one was the scariest one yet

Smerzi

This makes me hope they read My Immortal lmaoo

Allison Ramos

The detail in the gore and torture of this store legit made me a bit uncomfortable, which was weird to process considering this is an MLP story lol. But the Rascal Flats bit had me losing it LMAO

CrowAgainstMurder

Absolute gold lmao. I wonder if it's possible to play the copy righted music here on the patreon, maybe they're less strict than on YT? Idk this is the first time I've used patreon lol

jo

LMAOOOO

Saren Carroll

Legendary pull

Cynthia

Headphones on and laughing ..I had to explain this one to my bf 😂

Brandon Martinez

Peak

Aiden Parry

Omg yes I loved them. The one with the thumb could be a funny one. The scarecrow one is really good and honestly I love the illustrations from the original books I’d love to see some commentary on it

Purity

Unironically a goated read lol, wtf

Maegan McGee

The pony cupcakes reminds me of Curse of Strahd. IYKYK

coolsalad

Do yall think the mlp swat has body cam footage from cupcakes cia black site

mayo_nayz

Day 97 of requesting- Would be cool to watch you guys read through a collection of classics from the Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark books. There's three volumes so lots of good ones to pick from. They're also banned in a lot of schools now, thankfully not until after I graduated because I loved them and they scared the hell out of me, especially Harold the Scarecrow. It would be an awesome grab bag episode, not to mention the artwork by Stephen Gammell is excellent nightmare fuel. Plus: since it was a compilation of stories and folk tales, Alvin Schwartz, the author, did footnotes at the end of the books detailing some of the origins and variations of the stories, etc.

Josh G

The background music had me laughing the whole time. What a masterpiece.

fortnite big chungus amogus

Gypsy rose confirmed MLP character

maxton

Also, I DONT think this was written by a child. Which makes it even worse.

maxton

Hey everypony, this story literally made me nauseous 😄

Evyn

at least this means i wont have to hear this story at the live show

Julian Zarate

Top tier voice acting by Hunter

Brianna Blackfire

Erm… what teh Sigma???

The Possum King (DillaDong)

Banned from equestria flashbacks in black and white like a war.

Gracie

Someone needs to draw the pony versions of them please it would be fabulous

emme

i was eating a buccees brisket burrito and this story genuinely made me lose my appetite thanks guys for another great episode

Travibeelie

This ain’t it chief

Katie

Does this mean the costumes for the live show are going to be Pinkie Pie and Rainbow Dash?

EidolonReverie

*my comment is the dislike button for this comment*

Cantstopme427

This was the first episode of creep cast I didn't even finish hope next week's is better

RiotRat

Definitely should read Rainbow Factory too, I can't remember how the story went but the song based of it is still in my playlist 10+ years later lmao

Brayden Hopkins

Alright now we *need* a CreepTV episode on HotDiggedyDemon's Pony.mov series

zartek

I was laughing to tears at Hunter's improv at the background audio while Isaiah was reading the room scene

Possum Hands

Yes the mlp infection AU stuff on tik tok is legit cool

SaggyBalls27

i wish i could go back to before i listened to this.

Possum Hands

I LOVE SHED.MOV!!!!!! I had it saved on my flip phone 💀

Possum Hands

I had a massive brony phase. My middle school best friend's dad introduced us to it, and we obsessed over it all thru high school. I wore a ton of Rainbow Dash shirts, and had a deviant art account dedicated to mlp fan art. Also I had a crush on Macintosh since we're all being open and honest

Mamabear 0824

I started reading “house of leaves”. Looks like it’s going to be an interesting one…

Antony Chouffot

I think with Isiah moving they've had less time. I'd expect a longer episode soon. We did get mother horse eyes quite recently

Antony Chouffot

They come out at 6pm UK time and it's an ideal evening walk

John Guido IV

Ponies to the left of me, Pegasus to the right, here I am! Stuck in the middle with you!

Joshua B Stirewalt

Me and the 4 other Rascal Flatts fans on this channel are having a great time

SleepyGary137

They gotta do An Apple Sleep Experiment now

Grandpa with a Shotgun

I wouldn't assume the author was super young, it was more absurd than terribly written, probably intentionally. Seems like the gore even got Isaiah a bit lol

Tyler

This story is legitimately incredible

Matthew Powers

I remember watching the animation for this story when I was a kid at my friend's house and It scared me so badly I couldn't sleep at all that night. Same thing happened to me with Jeff the Killer, sonic. exe, and tails doll.

C Berg

The comments have me so excited 😂

Antony Chouffot

One of the best in terms of suspense and world building to goofy gore. Truly the Yin and Yang of CreepCast. Hope you had fun!

cas.ko

I can't say I expected a MLP smut fic to be the first creepcast episode I felt uncomfortable listening to at work but you guys made it happen, thanks everypony

Cameron Mouser

this may be the creepiest cast of all time

TrashKing

Don't get me wrong, it is disturbing, but I couldn't take it seriously

Antony Chouffot

I think he had higher energy and this is dialogue heavy so he just gets to be a good. Good chance this was recorded alongside the patreon ep where they were being goofy af. I get ya point though!

Willzyx

this makes me think of shed.mov, the channel hot diggedy demon does mlp parodies, they’re so good

Big Wolf

Same 😭

Big Wolf

Dear God lock that child up

Mags

So who’s gonna tell em about Fallout: Equestria

Poli

Me seeing the episode’s thumbnail: wow can’t wait for another goofy story written by a 8yr old in 2014! Me after finishing the episode: well, that was the most disturbing story ive ever heard

ERIC'S FOOT TIER LIST, WHEN? #IWILLNEVERFORGET

Jeeeeeeeeeeeezus

Weissman Adam

The unfettered cruelty of a young teen's mind on perfect display. Crazy that this is probably the most brutal thing they've read.

SaggyBalls27

i am so relieved to see someone else say this cause this fic had me sleeping with my bible for a week

packa zyns

wish Hunter had this energy for squidward suicide and the other short stories ep but better late than never i guess

TrashKing

This story would be more disturbing if it wasn't a "My Little Pony" horror story. That just makes it funny

NeoTorchwick

I remember as a teenager reading this and not being able to finish it because it was to brutal and disgusting, meanwhile now, I'm laughing my ass off, oh how deep dives into horror have changed me. xD

mitch

my biggest fear is that one day my headphones will disconnect at work and everyone around me finding out what i'm always listening to.

Andrew Greenhalgh

This is either inspired by or inspired Max G./Hotdiggitydemon's MLP parody series

pinkiekins

you have to dig more into mlp horror its such a specific niche like rainbow factory, smile, pony infection

acoustic_zebra

fun fact: there’s a pony based on doctor who in the show ⏳

Ben

Seeing the thumbnail gave me psychic whiplash, like my consciousness was blasted back fifteen years and then ripped back to the present

JackQuill

This may be, dare I say, the greatest story they have ever covered. First blackout now this. Absolute gold Peak storytelling

jimmy shogns

Just got tickets!!!

The Possum King (DillaDong)

WHERE YOUR FEARS AND HORRORS COME TRUE

moose

Second this

moose

☝️🤓

moose

Holy shit they actually did it, I remember seeing someone comment this. Love ts

T-Scribbs

Absolute gold.

Kitty

Every time rascal flatts started playing I absolutely lost it ☠️

W33vil_genius

OH MY GOD THEY COVERED CUPCAKES 😭 I was talking to my friend about funny it’d be if they did cupcakes

DeathRyder

How does she hold a knife

Rattle_em_up_jimmy

“ I was having a good time at the supermarket. Until I saw all the produce coming from , the creature “

Rattle_em_up_jimmy

Can we get a creep tv on shed.mov after this

Hannah Brinckerhoff

We NEED rainbow factory after this. This reminds me of watching the rainbow dash reads animations way back in the day!

EVAngelion

I cant listen to them at work because I laugh so hard everytime lmao

Michael Parker

All the people who seem to want them to read splatterpunk got their fix in the most unexpected way possible. What a magical place the internet is that you can find MLP splatter punk fan fiction. Really though it just reads like something a young boy wrote to gross out his MLP loving sister.

Mason

Good lord

Joshua Havens

Alright now read rainbow factory

Zack S

My little pony? Finally a scary story.

Marlowe Winter

Someone get iceberg boy out the backrooms!!!

Boonie Bound

Personally this is what I'm here for

Trey Culp

READ THE PREQUEL TO STOLEN TOUNGES

Boonie Bound

The background music completes the joke so well

CherryPieBomb

Pure Cinema

Alec and Katie Rose

Rascal Flatts playing in the background is making it very hard to keep a straight face at work 😭😂😂😂😂😂

John .A

Anton as a pony is frying me rn 💀

Slathosaur Porb

This was one of the greatest things I've ever seen. It took me two hours to watch because I kept laughing over likes and reminding

Anicearbiter

Over here doing MLP when creeptv is still left rotting smh

Slade

LETS GOOOOO

catfield

Never been more thrilled

Mahi★Gal

This gave me nightmares as a kid! Thank you for going over it boys!

Caprisun

Bro we need a pic of this author. That way I know to run if I am ever unlucky enough to run into them haha

Nic Truscello

Thats it. I'm calling the feds

Felix Jones

OH GOD NO THEY'VE FOUND IT

R

This would’ve fundamentally changed me if I read it in middle school

Steven

This reminded me of the movie, Law Abiding Citizen.

Gabbert

CreepTV with Cupcakes and Smile when🔊🔊

Altobelli Matias 237

the ed, ed and eddy creepypasta

Deiniik

Day 9 of asking for "The Supermarket Monster".

JaargusBaarg

i didn’t think i’d hear about a horse being crucified today lmao

Jeremiah Vires

Hunter made this episode Haven't laughed this hard in a while Thank you

koomsippa

An older balding man came into the coffee shop i work at with an entire MLP sleeve on his arm.

ty davie

now this is what i pay 5 bucks a month for

t4toon

please read rainbow factory i am begging you

CatPawsN’Accordion

You know, I just really want to be completely honest, listening to the disembowlment made my cramps even worse. So there’s that

Sarah Payne

I have waited on this FOR YEARS AHHH

MelaBaby

In high school I read A LOT of MLP creepypastas I think the worst ones were called grimdark? Idk but it was genuinely horrifying, I had literal nightmares of cartoon ponies doing awful things to me. 😭😭😭😭

Ashenvale

My boyfriend and I just finished Penpal and coming from that to this has been a TRIP.

Nancy Schultz

God, I hope the tour dates line up with the unsub second tour and they get to be guests again and vice versa. That would be legendary.

The Sharktocrab

Hunter thinks the ponies all sound like the Pillsbury doughboy for some reason

Harrison

A24 fastburn cinema

Zeroh074

The writer had to be a phycopath who was really into horses

Eden Anthony

What the fuck, dude.

Jacob Gates

I’m creeping it so hard right now 😫

B00L

Welcome back to cringe cast!

Moist Chungus

Now you have to do My Immortal…😤

Josh York

EDP guest read this episode?

Olivia Rowe

This is…. Dark

Riley H

I need to learn that I can’t listen to creep cast while I run errands. People in this Best Buy must think I’m insane for my reactions

John Armstrong

I love how in character Hunter is.

Stella

You know I really did expect something a lot worse 🤣

KaylaMoonShoes

I am listening to this walking through Lowes and now I feel dirty.

Raikhan

I hate that furries and bronies are on the same level 😭

Tanner M.

Recovering ex-Brony here. I will say one unique thing about the MLP fandom is how sometimes fan works (fanfic, art, comics, music, parody, etc.) would become almost as well known and popular within the fan base as the show itself. It was to the point where the creators of these works would basically be celebrities within the community, and would frequently get guest spots at conventions.

Josiah Virgil

All timer episode I think

RedDeathMask

Pinkie put a micky in dashes drinkie.

SalemWitch

IM WINNING

Yann Joanno

You can tell Hunter is having a blast with the voice acting in this one

Crazyme

I used to be a brony and I’m standing up and facing my cringe 🫡

necrosister

oh my god

Shadowsniper 37

I’ll cup your cake while I creep my cast 😎

Cameron Cook

Dear god

AB

Blessed be the paytch

piss shivers

Now everyone watch The Living Tombstones music video for September

Jervis Tetch

Hi guys I send the sequal to ted the caver as suggestion hope it found you well

igor

they listened!!!

BittyBoy

We are SO back lads

Kylie Riter

Hi fellow Creeps!

Crazyme

I’m chortling rn

Della Craig

No way i see the new episode thinking “omg i hope they talk about Weapons!!! :DD” only for it to be fucking cupcakes

Kaleb Mccubbin

Oh god, this is going to be nothing but crash outs

Kaylyn Thrasher

PLEASE omfg they have to do it

Maru

this is the craziest upload

Jessica

Had a friend who was an absolute MLP fan (we were maybe 11/12) and this animation made her crash outttt she warned me that I should never watch it because it was so scary, bad, gruesome,…

Amber Miner

okay i asked for The Rainbow Factory but im not about to complain. this is amazing

Wolfgang Starnes

You guys need to read Rainbow Factory. Please please please

Kaylyn Thrasher

BRONIE POSTING? NOT ON MY CHRISTIAN SUNDAY 😭

Jessica

Omgggg I know this will be funny I’m so stoked

KYRUTI

Shoutout Jenny Nicholson those videos are cool

High_Rat_King_Benis

Out there somewhere is a full on animation made about this story, no censorship or anything. Young me saw it on YouTube with no context for the story or my little pony in general. I was convinced it was adult animation for a long time after that, and I’d seen a special or something

♡ cherei ♡

You have to do Rainbow Factory now…

Niko Mathaldi

My cast is thoroughly creeped

IceAce96

“Something wholesome like Looney Tunes.” while doing a podcast with the “Rabbit Season” guy

Leroy Washington

Pretty please read Happy Appy

A Few Small Fish

This was completely unexpected but I am HERE FOR IT

King Fu

I gave you money and you did THIS WITH IT??

Tyler

I saw the thumbnail at lunch and hit the dog with his eyes closed meme

Shake

I gotta feeling we’re getting a Creepypasta grab bag mlp edition soon

hazyHelicopter

Oh no. I didn't think they would actually do it.

DeathOfMyEgo

I seen this come up and was like “no way it’s that story” but it in fact, was.

Carolina_Wildman

I’m truly surprised and so so happy y’all actually read this

Hentai King

Finally something good to eat

New Flesh

Incredible thumbnail

NotProudofThisStuff

As a former brony you guys have no idea how much of a stranglehold this version of Pinkie Pie had on the community at the time. Silent Ponyville and Rainbow Factory were also very popular

Mouse In Ur Pocket

After all this time yall are reading one of THE originals. Now you get to experience what ruined my generation's childhood

Inevitable Jackalope

My Little Pony ACAB merch would be ✨magical✨

Jarod Melito

Who up creepin they cast

Jonny

best thumbnail yet?

Aiden

The thumbnail...

Perrywinkle

eugh

Thomas St

this is the quality content we love

cameron zaloudik

Baes when are tickets coming out?

Alexis Howard

happy fucking sunday

JohnMichael

Short episode, but a fucking shotgun blast of a story

Nick R

Lonely Broadcast when?

BingoidOdyssey

Oh lord in Heaven

Professor Creepin

It’s you

HailiesHouse

I need y’all to post an hour earlier because my boyfriend gets back from his morning walk with his dog around now, and then I feel bad for wanting to ignore him to creep my cast 🫢😂