rchapman patreon

Early Release - What is Zionism? Pt. 2: The Creation of Israel

🕑 Added 2025-10-18 18:37:36 +0000 UTC

Comments

Aten

Fantastic video. Extremely enlightening to learn about the actual causes surrounding the creation of the state of Israel—instead of arguments about the current state of affairs. Q: Is the Patreon still open? Would love to join. University student in the UK seeking to discuss philosophy; esp Nietzsche, Foucault, Sartre, BAP.

Livio Accattatis

Congratulations Ryan. Excellent and monumental work - I thoroughly enjoyed it and learned a lot from it. Thank you! As per your question to the Patreon subscribers, I felt it flows pretty well. Looking forwards to the next instalment.

Ryan Chapman

Hi, ah that's a request I have not heard in a long time. For stuff that old I'd rather keep it private. The presentation is just not professional enough for the public eye, at least to me. Sorry. I hope you can understand.

eugene ionel

Hi Ryan. I wanted to watch your video about Political Correctnes, but it said it is private now. Is there a way to watch it?

Cedric

Per usual would expect nothing less from your work. Excellent job

Chieko

Hi Ryan, you educated me so much. Thank you. 2 small comments from me.. 1) Your talk can start when the first slide appears (so that audience can read introduction on you). 2) I felt there are too many slides flipping in some parts (so that I needed to watch twice to catch up with narrative), while the number of slides came comfortable toward the end (so that I could instantly follow your talk). Looking forward to your final version.

Bijan Shambayati

Incredible Video! Edited to perfection. A few comments/ critiques: Firstly (I’m unsure if this was noted in the first video): but Ashkénaze Jews have mixed European heritage, as well as middle eastern. This could perhaps add a bit of nuance and depth to the first section. Secondly, the part about Weizmann and Herzel is somewhat confusing, where you say that Weizmann was then leading opposition the heavily influenced by Herzel’s views (perhaps I simply misunderstood). Thirdly, in a later section, you speak about Damascus, saying it was part of Palestine, I believe that though there was sympathy and cohesion between Arabs in Syria and those in Palestine, Damascus was never part of the Palestinian state/occupation zone. //A smaller suggestion, it might be useful to add text of Names of important figures below in order for the audience to commit the name and face to memory together. An example of this perhaps: when showing the picture of Hussein Bin Ali (Sultan of Hejaz). I believe he was promised the Arabian Peninsula initially after the Ottoman defeat, though was pushed aside by the British in favor of different occupation zones. I hope these critiques can perhaps improve this already stellar content. Well done Ryan!

Nicolas Salliou

It is a great piece and, while I knew quite a bit about the history of Israel/Palestine I learnt quite a lot about internal dynamics of the Zionist movement. I just felt one or two times that the editing was going a bit fast over the written content, but overall it was not disrupting the flow (I just paused a bit 😅). Congrats for the great piece again and looking forward to the next part. Special like for the Churchill tree planting bad Omen anecdote.

Robin

Thanks, Ryan - great as always. Minor (very minor) thing to perhaps correct is the two documents at 40:54 don't appear to disappear as intended, and do so one after the other rather than at the same time. But that's all I noticed, and it may have been intentional. I'm looking forward to part 3!

Jim Matlock

Thank you Ryan. I really appreciate your perspective! It’s informed and insightful. Very helpful when trying to grasp what’s going on in that benighted part of the world.

Clayton Rosen

First watch, and wow! I would definitely say this was the most intrigued i’ve been in any of your videos so far (High praise considering i’m a patron.), the ending was excellent. I would say if I had any notes, I would like to know more of what the conscious was within the Palestinians, but given that this is a video on Zionism, and the fact you also did do some mentioning of the general feeling, and actions they took. I would consider that note to be minuscule. I think an important part you touched on was the factions within Zionism and how the idea evolved, it deepened an understanding of what I considered a one-note ideology. Relating to the Arab-Palestinian people from the time of 1920-1945 what books would you recommend to get a deeper idea of what the people where like at the time?

michelle4711

It's a helluva topic to try and unpick isn't it! It seems comprehensible, though I will likely go back and watch the first part again. And be waiting with bated breath for the next installment. I did think to myself that with the modern ability to view the wider context with such ease, all this information at our fingertips - would this ability have helped them avoid the mess. Just have to look at the mediascape today and realise no, it really wouldn't!