AfterNoona Delight Podcast patreon

This or THAT

🕑 Added 2022-10-13 19:00:06 +0000 UTC

Comments

Nina

I had similar thoughts! I like PMY dramas, she’s entertaining and cute, but because most of the roles I’ve seen her in have similar character profile (WWWSK, Her Private Life, Healer), I feel like I don’t know who she is as a person. I’d pick SMA as a gal-pal to hang out and grab a drink. She seems more “real” as a person, not just a character, probably due to the relatively more complex characters she played (Hometown Cha Cha Cha, Oh My Venus, Our Blues).

Karen McGuffey

Park Min Yun

Sarah @afternoonaasks

SMA, I do like PMY dramas but she’s probably for me one of the least versatile actresses

Claudia Copeland

Park Min Young for the range of her work over time. After watching Cha Cha Cha, I did watch quite a few of SMA’s earlier dramas; I wasn’t enchanted, although her more recent work is better and better. So, this is a tougher call than last week’s (😜), but PMY for me this time.

Megan Erickson

Hard agree. And they are a-dork-able together

Erin Miseyko

I have to with SMH. Oh My Venus was one of the first dramas I watched and while I do find parts of the drama very eye rolling and problematic I still one of my faves. While I like a-lot of dramas that PMY is in I don’t feel like the roles require a lot of range and tend to be similar.

Becky

This is hard!! Shin Min Ah seems more complex to me though, so I'm going to pick her. Plus she snagged Kim Woo Bin or he snagged her or however that worked out....so mad respect there too.

Daisy

She was in My Venus, which was very cheesy but cute. (If you can get past the whole weight weirdness) That review probably really makes you want to see it.🤦🏼‍♀️

Daisy

B- PMY she can be so good as a comedic actor. Forecasting was the only role I didn’t like for her but I didn’t like the drama either, a mismatch for couple. Healer, My Private Life, WWWSK…all good!!

Heather CK

I too think PMY's looking a bit too thin in LiC! ... and while I also agree that she portrays her characters well, her characters are all really similar to each other. I've seen SMA in 2 dramas and the characters were completely different, and so well done