RDM46 patreon

Redemption Reacts to NCT x aespa - ZOO | SMTOWN LIVE 2022 SMCU EXPRESS @ KWANGYA

🕑 Added 2022-01-14 18:03:32 +0000 UTC

Comments

Jayden

They had to cut some of the dance bc there singing live and they get tired fast!

Redemption 46 Studios

No thank you

Sadiya Mustapha

😊 thanks

Redemption 46 Studios

You might have to wait a little for that 🙏🏽

Redemption 46 Studios

Got you

Sadiya Mustapha

And please do the superM series mtopia we'll like to see your reaction to their chemistry despite the age difference and,coming from different groups

Sadiya Mustapha

Hello love your reactions,joined your patreon fam so I can recommend exo reactions, hope you'll do it thanks, its an acoustic medley part of their concert please react to it thanks https://youtu.be/vhT0QIQoGD8

Redemption 46 Studios

we did mad city lol.. got you on back 2 u tho

Guess

This might seem random (which it is) but I’m not sure where else to ask lmao but could y’all check out some 127 live performances like Mad City or Back 2 U??

Redemption 46 Studios

People crazy lol

Meliii

Damn, people getting feisty in here. All I know the song and choreo slaps!! Looking forward to more NCT MV reactions!!! Cherry Bomb, Superhuman and Simon Says!!

Redemption 46 Studios

Say less Sara lol

Redemption 46 Studios

😩😩😩😩

Hilary Angouing

Oh it makes a lot of sense but she ain’t even try honestly she really seemed like an outsider

Jennifer Ahweyevu

It wasn't her in the dance practice. The dance practice was just Taeyong and 4 dancers

Sara Seidu

If y'all want to see a female idol dance with the same energy as the dancer who danced as Giselle I recommend watching LILI's Film 1,2,3,4 Dance Performance Video and The Movie (they are short choreographies performed by BlackPink Lisa) . I would recommend to watch all of them at ones as they are just 1 to 1:30 minutes long , i know y'all will love it.😂😂

Hilary Angouing

Giselle baby imma need you to sit down and tell me wtf happened that you couldn’t execute the choreography here when you absolutely murdered it in the dance practice I don’t Stan aespa but as a girl I was rooting for you. Out here embarrassing me and my homegirls

Izak

isn't that because she sang the nword then said it was because she got carried away??/gen

Magical Creature

I don’t they all lack its just that in my eyes they have potential to be much better than they are now and i for sure know they could sing live many times with tight choreo if they had trained longer but now they have to improve in the public eye witch lets people bash on them and pick them apart it would have been better if Sm took their time with them and polished them fully. That was my point that i was trying to imply. English is not my first language so i tried my best to get it across

Jules

@DelesiaxAreum But she’s not dancing alongside trainees right now. She’s dancing next to people who have all been dancing professionally for 5 years longer than she has, so I’m just saying, of course she’s going to look even more awkward in comparison to their experience. I would hope in 5 years she would put on a better performance than this.

Magical Creature

I am a multistan and I didn’t bash Giselle i just said whole of Aespa would have benefited from a later debut because when u come from SM the expectations are much higher and if u lack in certain areas especially when aespa has only four members performing it is especially then noticeable so that makes them get more hate and All Sm Groups already have haters before they even debut so if they see them lacking they are gonna hate on them more. I gave my own opinion never said i was a pro at stage presence or any of that shit so please don’t take my words and twist it i said it as i see it. Everyone has their own opinion so don’t invalidate mine.

lana

nah fr deadass ik alot of idols who had less training period yet still come out and devour like they trained for yearsss

Redemption 46 Studios

LO and Jerrick were sick 😭😭😭

Redemption 46 Studios

Stop 😭😭😭😭

Lala woods

The disappointment 😭 Jerrick making excuses for Gisselle 😂 she was going through something. In Aespa she is not even the main dancer though so to put her with a group of guys who are on point with their dancing then that’s asking to be singled out cuz it is going to be obvious that she is lacking in that department so I think SM is the one to blame for putting her in this collaboration tbh.

Lady G

the op doesn't have to be a stage presence expert to use their eyes to see. Let people give their opinions and let Giselle grow, you are defending her from nothing. no one in this comment section is hating on her.

Lady G

I feel like you are doing a lil too much. She isn't getting hate in these specific comments, she is being critiqued. I dont see anything wrong with it.

Lady G

People saying its because Giselle had a short training period.... nah boo, if you not a dancer, you not a dancer. She's a rapper.

Jennifer Ahweyevu

That's because the other members are carrying her! Nobody has to be a stage presence expert to see she was lacking in this stage. It's not as obvious when she is with Aespa but it is still obvious she is the least prepared member

Doyoungismyult

yeah people in kpop have made it their mission to target her and say the nastiest things. It's quite sad really

Redemption 46 Studios

That’s true too…

Redemption 46 Studios

Yes we can

Redemption 46 Studios

Agreed 1000%… and idk

Redemption 46 Studios

I don’t watch them enough or pay attention to everything with them. Hopefully she grows into a stronger idol. She’s solid from what I see, she just in a company full of goats lol

DxAreum

1 reason if Sm decided her debut after 9 months of training! I expect her to be better than or be on the same level as a trainee who trained for 2 years or plus ! It will be logical to think if they choose her over trainees who trained way longer and who is really good than Giselle must be a beast on the stage as an performer which she is not ! She must work harder to keep up with others just because you're in a group and sharing the stage doesn't mean you should be satisfied at level with you are thinking you will hardly be seen

Redemption 46 Studios

She definitely was chillin.. Ppl just want to be mean

Redemption 46 Studios

Agreed

Redemption 46 Studios

Nice

DxAreum

Omg Thank You ! I TOTALLY Agree

Redemption 46 Studios

That’s true… I don’t think ppl should be bashing her. It’s ok to have an opinion but ppl definitely being nasty about it

J

Can you react to more Stray Kids

Magical Creature

Im sorry but with people using Giselles training period as a defense remember that there are many idols with lesser time than her for example Loonas Yve and olivia and Exo’s Baekhyun and Chen and Girl’s day Yura and Vixx’s Hyuk and they have more stage presence sorry to say it but SM should’ve deputed aespa members a year later to give them more time to perfect they’re skills they have great potential to improve but it’s SMs fault.

Redemption 46 Studios

Oh ok.. ppl being mean to her

Redemption 46 Studios

Ok that makes sense.. she was solid

Jules

1 vs 6 years experience is going to show, I don’t know why people expected any different. With that said I think Giselle did a great job for a one-off performance. This is not a title track, so this is not something they probably spent a significant amount of time on, and wasn’t she in Hyoyeon’s song too?

DxAreum

I feel like Giselle need more training all together! Like I felt like she debuted because of her Chebol status ! Giselle didn't have many lines in the song and she was rapping! She wasn't hitting high notes or singing ! Even in aspea live stages she lacks in stage presence behind the others! Yall trying use her training period as excuse and this maybe controversial but she is not naturally gifted at dancing, rapping, or singing. She dosen't look like she was born to do this like other girls ! She most likely one of those people who have to work extra hard to get it than others which is nothing wrong with that! She need put her all in performance and practice over and over ! It was very mediocre I seen trainees with 2 months of experience who did better! She probably fine with her mediocre performances because that what SM Accepts from her ! People need be hard on her so she can be better ! There are thousands of trainees who way are talented who dosen't even get the chance to debut !

Shanz

I'm not an Aespa Stan or anything but Giselle did fine. You can't really compare her to like professional dancers ( Bada Lee is like top top tier) Of course it would seem underwhelming in comparison. Giselle also hasn't trained that long in dance. Knowing that I think she did good. Also Nct are like really strong dancers. I feel like people were being a little hard on Giselle.

Elizabeth Seravello

I gotta say, I agree with you about her not being as "hard" as the NCT members, cause NCT is just known to move like that

Charlene Newton

Bada Lee and Taeyong did the choreo for this.

Doyoungismyult

You also have to keep in mind that the dancers were only dancing. They were not singing at the same time or performing. That’s a whole different ball game. Giselle is much better at rapping then dancing though. She only trained for 9 months. It almost seems like they rushed her debut.